Support Your Teachers With a Better System for Growth and Evaluation

Support Your Teachers With a Better System for Growth and Evaluation
Support Your Teachers With a Better System for Growth and Evaluation

Academic Leadership

Teachers are in the classroom every day with your students, ensuring your mission is delivered with excellence. Faculty members interface with your parents and community, making them some of your most important brand ambassadors and keys to re-recruitment. In short, good teachers are a vital asset to a successful school.

But when it comes to teacher evaluation, traditional systems just aren’t working as well as they should be. Typical evaluations often rely on short, sporadic classroom observations conducted by busy administrators. These visits are an extremely small window into the ongoing and highly personal education process.

From a 20-minute observation, administrators might share a few notes on how to grow and a few notes on what they believe needs improvement. It feels rushed, impersonal, and incomplete.

According to ISM’s research, only 51% of teachers agree or strongly agree that their evaluation procedures are consistent or constructive. That’s a failing test score.

Many teachers feel evaluations are less about supporting effective teaching and more about fixing what is perceived to be wrong. These evaluations erode trust between administrators and teachers, because teachers often don’t feel supported—they feel judged.

Give Teachers the Tools to Thrive

We believe that by separating the key processes of growth and evaluation, schools can encourage teachers to pursue research-based, innovative new approaches to teaching and learning.

Teachers are given the freedom to innovate and inspire in the classroom—without fear of repercussion. Leaders can also ensure HR compliance through evaluation systems that keep teachers in line with essential expectations for actions and behaviors.

Empower and Inspire Teachers

This approach can have significant benefits for your school’s teachers. They will receive ongoing, meaningful feedback to support their growth—separate from their performance evaluations.

This empowers teachers to maintain growth mindsets. They will feel encouraged to try new things in the classroom because those outcomes aren’t tied to compensation or employment status. Teachers can feel confident that the administration understands the intricacies of teaching in the classroom, building a culture of trust.

When teachers feel trusted and supported, this often leads to better student outcomes, increasing student performance, satisfaction, and enthusiasm.

Support Your School’s Success

Your school will also benefit from this approach. When there is trust between administrators and the faculty, teachers know that the school has their best interests in mind. This often makes the administration’s feedback more easily accepted.

Administrators also provide predictability with an evaluation system that holds faculty accountable with clear expectations for performance and professionalism. Everyone knows what to expect—and what is and isn’t acceptable.

Finally, by separating growth and evaluation, each process is given the time and attention it deserves. They are seen as independent and equally important elements of supporting your school’s teachers.

ISM recently published Comprehensive Faculty Development: A Guide to Attract, Retain, Develop, Reward, and Inspire as a road map to solving the systemic problems associated with growth and evaluation in private schools. Discover how to separate growth from evaluation to reframe the very structure and culture that surrounds these systems to transform the way your school supports its faculty. If you’re looking for a bit more support, our Consultants can help you implement this framework at your school.


Comprehensive Faculty Development: A Guide to Attract, Retain, Develop, Reward, and Inspire

Additional ISM resources:
The Source for School Heads Vol. 17 No. 9 Why Traditional Teacher Evaluation Doesn’t Work—And What You Can Do About It
The Source for School Heads Vol. 17 No. 3 Your Faculty Holds the Key to an Effective Re-Recruitment Strategy
The Source for School Heads Vol. 16 No. 1 Are Your Faculty Evaluations Effective?

Additional ISM resources for members:
I&P Vol. 43 No. 11 The Problem(s) With Teacher Evaluation


Explore ISM’s 40+ professional development events.

Develop new skills, gain confidence in your role, and lead with clarity. Be mentored by leaders who are experts in their field, many currently working in private schools today. Get hands-on experience, network with fellow school leaders, and walk away with an action plan you can use the minute you return to campus.



Upcoming Events

6/22/2021 — 6/24/2021


Strategic Financial Planning: A Comprehensive Approach

Status: Open


7/20/2021 — 7/22/2021


Virtual Advancement Summit

Status: Open


More Events

  • workshop 6/21/2021 — 6/25/2021

    Chairing Your Department: The First Five Years

  • workshop 6/28/2021 — 6/30/2021

    Mastering Enrollment Management in a Post-COVID-19 World

  • workshop 7/12/2021 — 7/15/2021

    High-Performing Teams: Managing Up, Down, and Sideways